The STC controversy: making a mountain out of a molehill

The frolicking high school students

The St. Theresa’s College controversy is about an exclusive all-girls catholic school in Cebu City that disallowed five high school students from participating in their graduation ceremonies for allegedly violating the school’s handbook.

I would presume that, being an exclusive school for girls and a catholic institution founded by the Missionary Sisters of the Immaculate Heart of Mary (ICM), the school’s handbook speaks more of the Christian values that a girl should possess and how to comport oneself as a Theresian, both in and outside of school. All these are hammered into the student’s head from the time they enter kindergarten until they graduate from college.

Now enter the five high school students whose antics, days before their slated graduation, caught the ire of the school principal, Sister Celeste Ma. Purisima Pe, which resulted to the unfortunate controversy.

What can you do if five young girls feeling in seventh heaven for having finished high school at last, and now poised to enter college, are frolicking in celebration with abandon?

Facebook enthusiasts that these girls are, they uploaded photos which were deemed as inappropriate and unbecoming of a Theresian by the school officials.

The pictures allegedly showed the students posing in a bikini, doing what is deemed as ‘dirty dancing’, and drinking alcoholic beverage.

Why put malice on their skimpy swimsuits and their actions if they were around a swimming pool? What makes the whole thing indecent? Let them celebrate freedom for whatever it meant to them that very moment. Let them fool around. Let them pretend and role-play, after all there is no stopping the distinction that pretty soon each one of them will be called a woman.

Does that make them cheap in the eyes of people? Were they debasing the school? Were they corrupting their morals? Don’t they all come from respectable families? Do you think they were spoofing with the intention of shaming their parents? After all these years don’t the teachers, including Sister Celeste, know them well in school?

Instead of being prudent, Sister Celeste’s myopic view and prudishness went overboard, thus causing undue anxiety to the girls and their parents.

Is this enough reason to punish them by excluding them in the graduation rites?

This controversy has gone from bad to worst when STC defied the order of the court to allow the students, who were earlier barred from joining the graduation rites, to take part in the high school commencement exercises of the school.

Regional Trial Court Judge Wilfredo Navarro issued a temporary restraining order (TRO) directing the school to cease and desist from enforcing the penalties on the graduating students.

What I am simply saying is this: Does the controversy had to go this far where parents are bringing the school authorities to court for their unjust and ill-considered decision?

After having built up a solid attachment between the school and parents, how could it be possible that for one frivolous mistake the school authorities led by Sister Celeste could just brush aside the loving respect and affection that one has for the other?

If, indeed, Sister Celeste saw some irregularities in the action/behavior of the students, as reflected in the FB, could she just not have called the parents involved for a meeting and bring up with them the issue of deviancy committed by their daughters as far as the school is concern?

Isn’t having an understanding and agreement – a meeting of minds – about what is right and wrong, what has been obeyed and violated regarding school precepts, the appropriate and the most Christian way of coming to terms and resolving the issue?

Isn’t reminding the young students about rectitude of conduct taught by the school and counseling them of their folly and forgiving them afterwards a Christian teaching?

Why then make a subjective decision brought about by whimsical anger and false perception which only brings nothing but discord in the community?

Why make a mountain out of a molehill?


5 comments on “The STC controversy: making a mountain out of a molehill

  1. Salaryman Ryan says:

    I thought that STC handled this situation poorly. Perhaps in hind sight everything is 20/20 but I believe that the principal should have followed the example of Christ and showed more compassion to these kids. They’re kids for Goodness sakes, and kids do a lot of silly stuff. Tell them to take down the offending photo, give them some extra school work or let them attend classes on values and teach them why posting half naked photos of themselves on Facebook is not such as moral or smart thing to do. In the end everyone will be thankful for that. What the principal and authorities of STC with their drastic action is drag everyone’s name in the mud – yes that includes STC.

  2. proud to be says:

    you don’t know the full story..STC admin still cares for the students reputation , not to let the public know what really happens..there is a story behind the picture..did you know even their co graduates were ready to show protest if the 5 students will be able to attend their graduation..? you as parents do you like your 16year old girls drink and smoke and Someting else???

    • quierosaber says:

      My only contention is, why make it traumatic for the young girls. We should realize, and the school should much more realize than we do, that the students are all minors. Isn’t it enough that they be called and lecture them on where they went wrong and at some point call the parents also and tell them where they were remiss in looking after the conduct of their children? All is needed is constructive criticism that will make all of them see the point from the school’s perspective. Blowing it up simply distorts and destroys everything. This is what destructive criticism does, especially when arrogantly publicized.

  3. Lance Leander L. Cembrano says:

    It was not blown over. It’s not a molehill. It was handled appropriately.

    Do you really think that kids who have been informed and educated about Christian morality, ethics, and values (for years!), and yet still engage in wearing immodest and indecent clothing, and the purchase and consumption of liquor/ alcoholic drinks, can be reformed with a simple slap on the wrist? That is beyond naive and lets kids off the hook way too easily. Discipline and laws must be enforced. They should even by charged for the underage/ illegal drinking and possession of alcoholic drinks.

    Jesus Christ gives compassion and forgiveness to those who sincerely seek those things, and repent of their sins. Turning a blind eye because “they’re just kids who are celebrating freedom” is un-Christian, and severely irresponsible. So, what? You’re fine with having kids dressing up like sluts/ whores, and drinking their livers to death regardless of the morality that you tried to teach them? That’s plain stupid.

    They went to a Christian school willingly, and that means they must to abide by its rules. God takes morality and sin very seriously. And His forgiveness may cleanse sin, but it does not remove the consequences of sin. Eve and Adam sinned, they were forgiven, but the consequences of their actions, which are original sin and being kicked out of Eden, cannot be avoided. They earned those consequences. These kids sinned, God may forgive them if they sincerely and truly repent of their sins, and turn away from them, but that does not remove the consequences of their horrible choices.

    Do not forget that a parent must be a parent first, before being a “friend” to his/ her kids. Or what, do you enjoy seeing kids run amok? Is parental supervision, abiding by the laws, and adhering to objectives morals, ethics, and values that horrible?

Let me know what you think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s